I believe it depends on the person wether or not they will enjoy being homeschooled. For me it's the best thing ever because I'm not a very social person, and I have two wonderful siblings either way to keep me company at home (when they're not at school, that is). Also, If I hadn't been homeschooled I would have had to go to the school near my house and that thing has a horrible aura, it's like there's a portal leading straight to hell under it or something... You almost expect to turn a corner and see a demon, it's really that bad. But now we found a new school that is much better, and even if I'll have to take the bus to get there every morning, I won't mind going there next year.
my general opinion is this: homeschooling can be a great thing to do but not if you are isolated without anyone your age. You must have contacts with other people but not online,in real life,and you need to go out. Especially if you are a teenager.
I agree with your general opinion, except for having human interactions in real life. For normal people sure, but people like me who have less social skills than a scarecrow prefer to be hermits and never see anyone that isn't family or friends I've known for a long time (meaning none for me, but my parents have friends and they're fine, I don't mind them).