Republic Islamic and Kingdom of Iran

  • 536
  • 13
  • 61

Sir, I appreciate that you are trying to think critically about complex international issues. However, I must respectfully disagree with your viewpoint, because it closely resembles the characteristics of conspiracy theories as I know them: making sweeping claims without evidence, attributing everything to Western media, or labeling it as a Western plot.

I am very familiar with this way of thinking. Similar ideas continue to be widespread in China’s online environment, and I also believed in them wholeheartedly when I was in middle school. However, as I grew older and gained more understanding of the world, I realized how misguided such thinking is.

As a Chinese person, let me give an example based on my experience living in China. From modern to contemporary times, some of my fellow citizens have long trusted the saying “Learn from the West to counter the West.” This saying, which means “learn foreign technologies to compete with them,” reflects a historical strategy of strengthening one’s own country by adopting advanced technologies from abroad.

But the problem is obvious: leaders of Western countries are not going to be that foolish—to teach technology while others use it against them. This way of thinking, based on “learning from the West to counter the West,” clearly contradicts common sense and basic ethical principles. In fact, this idea has proven to be misguided, as Western countries have begun to refuse to teach, sell, or even sanction certain technologies to China.

Unfortunately, some of my fellow citizens still do not recognize this, and in China’s online discourse, claims like “The West is restricting our development” or “The West fears China’s rise and refuses to sell technology” are rampant, along with many other similar ideas.

I have always considered this reasoning foolish. In my view, the government is exhausting its credibility, and once that credit is used up, China risks becoming isolated as a global adversary. Of course, I would never post such opinions on Chinese social media, because others have already done so—and the result was that their accounts were banned, and they were labeled by some as “traitors” or “collaborators.” From my own perspective, witnessing this has made me cautious about expressing controversial opinions online. This makes it extremely difficult for ordinary people to express dissenting opinions safely. Simply put, to live a healthy and happy life in China, one cannot express opinions or speech that are perceived as unfavorable to the government.

In summary, modern people all live in their own worlds, and online “information silos” still exist. Therefore, I would not recommend spreading such conspiracy theories without evidence. From my own life experience, I have come to understand that foolish ideas are contagious, especially to those who, like my younger self in middle school, lacked real-life experience. Therefore, I hope everyone approaches such claims with caution and critical thinking, and takes the time to verify information and reflect on historical lessons.🤔🤔

OK! So you think that the Iran protests are also just CONVENIENTLY happening in accordance with the "Project for a new American century" wish list?

Disagree, all you want. You have your opinions based on info that is public. There's so much more beneath the surface is that the common man don't know about.
So... do I disagree with you as I see your opinion based on lies and propaganda and no information about the military and economic interest these people have talked about since 1998 PUBLICLY, but not splattered in your face in the news. You have to look it up for yourself.

That involves taking down everything from Libya to Afghanistan that is not obedient to the globalist agenda.
A little TOO convenient that Iran ALSO happen to be on that list!
Don't you think! Can't take them through military force?
Do it by a funding insurgents and starting a revolution!
This ofc goes above the average person ability to understand, but that's how psychological operations are done.
You're not supposed to realize that one was going on. You're supposed to think it all developed organic.

But Afghanistan kicked NATO out in 2022??? Yeah, you keep telling yourself that.
They simply installed a puppet regime there. Who do you think gave them all that hi-tech gear they have now?
I'll give you a hint! IT WAS THE AMERICANS! They left it all behind!
Go on! Speak to someone who was there! They'll confirm it. Tanks, cars, weapons, hi-tech gear. Left it all there for them!

For me i think the most important is what the people want in Iran. And if they protest and they are killed that is wrong even if other countries helped that they protest. But in any case they cant be killed for demonstrating or what they want. But Iran is not a democracy and i believe that ppl should be free that they decide things themselves.


So safety is the most important. I dont know others from Iran than Parsa but i hope that there is peace really soon.

OK! So you think that the Iran protests are also just CONVENIENTLY happening in accordance with the "Project for a new American century" wish list?

Disagree, all you want. You have your opinions based on info that is public. There's so much more beneath the surface is that the common man don't know about.
So... do I disagree with you as I see your opinion based on lies and propaganda and no information about the military and economic interest these people have talked about since 1998 PUBLICLY, but not splattered in your face in the news. You have to look it up for yourself.

That involves taking down everything from Libya to Afghanistan that is not obedient to the globalist agenda.
A little TOO convenient that Iran ALSO happen to be on that list!
Don't you think! Can't take them through military force?
Do it by a funding insurgents and starting a revolution!
This ofc goes above the average person ability to understand, but that's how psychological operations are done.
You're not supposed to realize that one was going on. You're supposed to think it all developed organic.

But Afghanistan kicked NATO out in 2022??? Yeah, you keep telling yourself that.
They simply installed a puppet regime there. Who do you think gave them all that hi-tech gear they have now?
I'll give you a hint! IT WAS THE AMERICANS! They left it all behind!
Go on! Speak to someone who was there! They'll confirm it. Tanks, cars, weapons, hi-tech gear. Left it all there for them!

“Dear sir,

It seems we are examining this matter through rather different lenses, which in itself makes the discussion most… illuminating.

While our conclusions may diverge, I hold your perspective in due respect.

Thank you for taking the time to share your observations.

With all due courtesy, I bid you good day.”

I've finally managed to access this site after weeks. The situation has been truly strange in recent weeks.

I can answer any question you might have. I'll just say this: don't pay too much attention to these Iranian monarchist groups. They are against unity and are nothing more than a noisy minority.

The struggle of Iranians for democracy has a history of over 100 years, and we still haven't achieved it. But we will.

I am really worried for @Parsaa and also @SkepticCyclist and everybody in Iran bc on the Dutch news now everywhere they say that there may be war really soon and that there are a lot of preparations of America for it. From the birthday list i know that @Parsaa has his birthday on 1 February and i hope that the BIGGEST present that maybe he gets is that it can finally be PEACEFUL in Iran and that ppl can decide what happens with their country and that nobody has to be afraid of more war or a lot of violance bc of the demonstrations. 🙏⭐✨🌸🙏

I am really worried for @Parsaa and also @SkepticCyclist and everybody in Iran bc on the Dutch news now everywhere they say that there may be war really soon and that there are a lot of preparations of America for it. From the birthday list i know that @Parsaa has his birthday on 1 February and i hope that the BIGGEST present that maybe he gets is that it can finally be PEACEFUL in Iran and that ppl can decide what happens with their country and that nobody has to be afraid of more war or a lot of violance bc of the demonstrations. 🙏⭐✨🌸🙏

Parsaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

Fearing for Iranian lives is good but more importantly pressure your governments to take action and hold the Iranian regime accountable. There is much they can do, yet they choose not to. Thank You.
-------------
Regarding the user Parsa, I looked into the data of those who lost their lives in the recent Iranian uprising; I found at least four people named Parsa, but it doesn't seem to be any of them. The youngest among them was 17. So, don't worry. These days, Iranians just don't have the heart or the spirit for many of the things they used to do.
Edited by SkepticCyclist .

Parsa is a very intelligent, tenacious and ambitious boy 👍

Was it right to attack Iran? This question isn't very important to me. My question is different: Is it right that children, boys, girls, men, women, elderly people, and sick people are dying today from this attack? And Parsa? Where is Parsa? Is he still alive? Is he dead? Parsa with all his dreams and plans for the future. And so many other young Iranians with their dreams. A man in Jerusalem and a man in Washington have decided to decide Iran's fate. Not to free Iran from a horrendous government, but simply to defend the interests of two nations that are sowing death throughout the world.

Just catching up on the news. Has the death of Khamenei been confirmed by official Iranian sources? It remains to be seen which chain of events is triggered by the military strike in perhaps one of the most volatile regions in the world. I am not sure whether any main party in this sinister segment of world politics can contain the looming chaos.

Yes it has been confirmed. But these people have each appointed up to four deputies. Even without bomb attacks, they have probably learned from the Mossad's pager attackers.
The biggest danger is now: If the Revolutionary Guards and the country's leadership fear they have nothing left to lose, they will probably launch even worse attacks against their own people.

At the end of Nazi Germany in 1944/45, Hitler also “did not shed a tear for the German people” and led everything destroyed and every member of the opposition, no matter how small, killed. And in the end some of them just committed suicide.

I agree that the stance of the RG may create a pressure cooker within domestic boundaries. The extent to which the population is willing to take the streets with a critical mass following recent events - not to mention continuing bombing - remains to be seen. The big question remains whether the US intends to put boots on the ground - which seems unlikely.


Another uncertain feature is the turmoil that may be caused by the Shiite diaspora across the larger region. It was not just an assassination of a head of state, but also of a religious leader with a significant following. I am not in a position to make any reasonable prediction on these matters. With Iraq, Afghanistan and other past interventions in mind, I hesitate whether the US has appropriate contingency planning in place.

The danger is also: When the regime changes and you have masses of military officers with no perspektive and unempliymence the next IS is in start.

They shouldnt repeat the same mistakes like after Iraq.

What do you guys think following the attacks in Iran? Im very curious to know whether this will lead to a progressive regime change or will Khomenei just be replaced with someone else? Also do we think this is going to aspect the world?

In the absence of either Galactic or Divine intervention, the situation in Iran and the wider region is precarious and utmost volatile. My limited understanding of the strike on Khamenei is that it involved an opportunistic attack due to the proximity of various leaders in the ayatollah’s compound (including high ranking RG and Def Min officials). The lack of proper contingency planning and military ground support by US would mean that the current status quo can be fertile ground for new representatives of the “old” regime or more extreme militant organisations to prosper. I consider it unlikely that IS (or similar) Sunnite groups would assume control in a predominantly Shiite society. But the current void will not persist.


Immediate effects in the broader region are already visible (including possible incursion by Israel in the southern part of Lebanon). The big question is whether Shiite factions in neighboring countries of Iran will respond and further ignite existing tensions.


Welcome to casino politics on a global level - as it seems to be the case. It is a dire situation in which chaos will likely continue to thrive in the near future at the expense of local populations.

Do you think it’s possible for the shah to come back rule?

No, I guess the society changed complete and Im sure the young Iran population don´t want a "one man show" again.

My friend is Iranian and she was telling me that her family really want the shah to come back…